“If anthropological data suggests something short of the ideal, that is not because nothing is universal, but because two universals are in conflict: universal moral knowledge and universal desire to evade it. The first one we owe to our creation. The second we owe to our fall.”
What we can't not know Quotes
Verified quotes and passages from What we can't not know (2003) by J. Budziszewski, with MLA, APA, and Chicago citations.
“If he makes humanity God and yet cries out against God's inhumanity, it is clear who has really been accused.”
“Those are just platitudes. Everyone has his own idea of 'playing fair.' 'Does he? Try making up your own idea of what's fair--say, 'giving the greatest rewards to the laziest workers'--and see how seriously people take you.”
“It is hard enough to face the moral law even with the revelation that the divine justice and divine mercy are conjoined. It offends our pride to be forgiven, terrifies it to surrender control.”
“Trying to understand man without recognizing him as imago Dei is like trying to understand a bas-relief without recognizing it as a carving.”
“Besides, morality is not about whether the human race survives, but about what kind of survival it gets. We marry; guppies don't. We don't eat our young; they do. Yet neither species is in danger of extinction.”
“When, despite considerable intelligence, a thinker cannot think straight, it becomes very likely that he cannot face his thoughts.”
“Even the suicide desires his own good: he wrongly imagines that he would be better off dead. The moral problem is not that we love ourselves but that we love ourselves the wrong way.”
“In the same way, filling a cavity restores to the tooth its natural function of chewing. Healing does not transcend our nature; it respects it.”
“Yet our common moral knowledge is as real as arithmetic, and probably just as plain. Paradoxically, maddeningly, we appeal to it even to justify wrongdoing; rationalization is the homage paid by sin to guilty knowledge.”
“How conscience tells us that we ought to be fair, nobody knows. This we can say: we don't know it just from being told, we don't know it from the five senses, and we don't know it by inference from prior knowledge. We just know it. The knowledge is 'underived.”
“Or perhaps the syndrome we are witnessing is preemptive capitulation: If we reduce our conscience to rubble before the bad men get here, they will have nothing to destroy.”